When choosing the best diagnostic tool for Mercedes vehicles, the Mercedes Star Machine system is indeed the gold standard. Here’s a detailed breakdown based on your overview:
Why Choose the Mercedes Star Machine?

Accuracy & Depth: It provides unrivaled diagnostic precision, catering specifically to Mercedes models.
Comprehensive Capabilities: Includes diagnostics, programming, software updates, event logs, and repair guidance.
Factory-Level Access: Offers insights and features that generic tools can't match.

Essential Software for Star Machines:

Xentry: For vehicles from 2009 onward, this is the most up-to-date diagnostic tool.
DAS: Handles diagnostics for models from ~1999/2000 to 2009 and some newer ones.
WIS (Workshop Information System): A library of repair manuals and procedures.
EPC (Electronic Parts Catalog): For part lookups and detailed diagrams.
Vediamo & DTS Monaco: Advanced programming and engineering-level diagnostics (optional).

Comparison of Mercedes Diagnostic Tools:
1. Mercedes Benz C3:

Strengths: Affordable and effective for older models.
Limitations: Outdated and discontinued (2013), supporting only wired connections.

2. Mercedes Benz SD C4:

Strengths: Reliable, widely compatible, wireless, and supports modern protocols (K-Line, CAN, UDS).
Best Use: A balanced option for professionals servicing various Mercedes models.

3. Mercedes Benz SD C5:

Versions:
C4 in a C5 casing: Essentially a rebranded C4.
Genuine C5: Enhanced features and support for DOIP protocols.
Considerations: Pricier and more challenging to upgrade, but worth it for high-end or newer vehicles.

4. Mercedes Benz SD C6 (VCI):

Strengths: The fastest and most advanced option, supporting all protocols, including DOIP.
Caveats: Aftermarket versions can have compatibility issues with DAS. Best suited for technicians focusing on newer Mercedes models.

Final Recommendation:

For general diagnostics across a wide range of models, SD C4 is ideal due to its balance of functionality, cost, and ease of use.
If servicing newer vehicles is the primary focus, consider investing in the SD C6, ensuring you choose an authentic version to avoid compatibility issues.
For engineering-level diagnostics and programming, incorporate tools like Vediamo and DTS Monaco with the chosen Star Machine.

__________________
When you encounter a problem, try to find a way to solve it. Hope to learn and share some information about Mercedes-Benz car diagnosis（www.autonumen.com）